by slamatattorneys | Jul 6, 2021 | Media Law
Media Law – The Fulcrum for Free Speech – Ashley Slamat Attorneys – no games, Just Law™
Media law is that branch of South Africa’s substantive law which deals with the various aspects of the legality of the media, also known as the press.
Cursorily, media law involves the following aspects of the law in regard to freedom of speech (and freedom from censorship) in the context of the Constitution:
- print media;
- digital media;
- broadcasting and telecommunications;
- the Film and Publications industry including the regulation of pornography;
- court reporting duties of the media and it’s concomitant responsibilities;
- delictual or tort liability of the media for defamation, insult or crimen injuria;
- advertising law and the promotion of fair competition via the media;
- interception and monitoring of communications by the media;
- disclosure of information and whistle-blowing in the media;
- restrictions of the information pertaining to state security.
Obviously, media law is vital and essential in any constitutional democracy as it protects the rights of citizens to freedom of speech and also their freedom to unpopular speech. George Orwell once said that “if freedom of speech means anything, then it means that right to tell a man something which he does not want to hear”. Consequently, unpopular speech is absolutely vital for the health of any free nation.
Furthermore, media law is imperative in the protection and promotion of the right not be subjected to censorship by the will of the State (or it’s agents) in permitting it’s citizens to know only what it wants citizens to know. In this context, the right to decide for oneself (and not to be regarded as a sheep) is an absolute inherent human right. Undoubtedly, media law is the fulcrum of free speech.
In South Africa, certain pieces of legislation (in whole or in part) may be regarded as an infringement of the right to freedom of speech (including its other inherent rights), these laws being, inter alia, the following:
- Official Secrets Act 16 of 1956;
- Protection of Information Act 84 of 1982;
- Internal Security Act 74 of 1982;
- Petroleum Products Act 120 of 1977;
- National Supplies Procurement Act 89 of 1970;
- National Key Points Act 102 of 1980;
- Post Office Act 44 of 1958
- Interception and Monitoring Prohibition Act 127 of 1992;
- Regulation of Interception of Communications and Provision of Communication-related Information Act 70 of 2002 (RICA)
While the following laws may be regarded as forms of protection of the rights of freedom of speech (including its other inherent rights) and the right not be censored:
- Protected Disclosures Act 26 of 2000;
- Telegraph Messages Act 44 of 1963;
- Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 (sections 189(1), section 205(1) and (4);
- Promotion of Access to Information Act 2 of 2000;
- Public Protector Act 23 of 1994 (formerly known as the Ombudsman in terms of the Ombudsman Act 118 of 1979 and the Advocate General in terms of the Advocate General Act 118 of 1979;
- Explosives Act 26 of 1956;
- Conservation of Agricultural Resources Act 43 of 1983;
- Human Tissue Act 65 of 1983;
- Electronic Communications & Transactions Act 25 of 2002;
- Electronic Communications Act 36 of 2005;
- Films and Publications Act 65 of 1996;
- Copyright Act 98 of 1978;
- Electoral Act 73 of 1998;
- Competition Act 89 of 1998;
- Mental Health Act 17 of 2002;
- Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998;
- South African Police Service Act 68 of 1995.
Consequently, in South Africa it is vital that all aspects of media law should be protected and advanced to the utmost degree in any constitutional democracy while advocating that it is useless to argue taste and even more useless to litigate it.
www.slamatlaw.co.za
Ashley Slamat Attorneys – Copyright
by slamatattorneys | Jun 22, 2021 | Family Law
Step-parents and step-children? Are their any “rights”. The answer is NO.
Evidently, this question is becoming more prominent in the contact we are receiving from clients. Perhaps the question is being asked more frequently due to the times which we are living in or because it is a question which has become more irritating or upsetting to couples in a relationship where one or both of the partners have a child(ren) from another relationship.
It is said that once a relationship is over, then it is over.
However, it appears that many couples are plagued by the incessant demands or issues from a disgruntled ex step-parent, which causes this question to be raised with us more and more frequently.
In lay man’s terms, a step-parent is one whom has no biological nexus to the child concerned and is married the child’s biological mother or father.
In South African law prior to the coming into law of the Children’s Act in 2007 such a step-parent never obtained any ‘rights’ to the step-child. While the step-parent is bound by the common law duties and responsibilities owed to their spouse this did not include any duties or responsibilities to the step-child per se as a father or mother. Had the step-parent adopted the step-child, the legal position would be somewhat different. However, absent an adoption or other court order, the step-parent never obtained any rights to the step-child by virtue only of the marriage to the child’s mother or father. Once the marriage is over, there are no ‘rights’ which automatically exist for the step-parent in respect of the step-child no matter how long the marriage endured. It is simply one of the aspects of life which a step-parent accepts when entering into a relationship with the child’s parent, be it the child’s mother or father.
In the case of the parent of the child being in a relationship with a ‘partner’, i.e. when there is no marriage but merely a relationship, the above legal position is exactly the same except for there being no common law duties and responsibilities between the adults.
Since the coming into operation of the Children’s Act in 2007, the above legal position in South African law remains the same. While there are provisions in the Act which enable certain persons to bring matters pertaining to children before the courts (with the intention being at all times that such matters are brought in the child’s best interests) and not in the interests of the adults filing such matters, the Act itself, despite being a very liberal piece of legislation, does not provide at all for any substantive statutory ‘rights’ of a step-parent in regard to step-parents and step-children.
This is certainly the correct approach and legal position in regard to step-parents and step-children. One can only imagine the chaos and social upheaval that would arise if step-parents acquired any substantive ‘rights’ to children who are not their own.
After all, bearing and rearing one’s own children in accordance with your will is a God given right for the child’s biological parents, unless such parent(s) is unfit or otherwise unable to exercise those special God given rights.
We point out that in the context of parenting plans, we advocate our firmly held view that it is insensible and injudicious to include any terms pertaining to step-parents in parenting plans which should, in the normal course, remain the plan of only the child(ren’s) biological parents at all times.
www.slamatlaw.co.za
by slamatattorneys | Jun 21, 2021 | Criminal Law
Search & Seizure Laws – What Constitutes a Legal Search & Seizure?
Ashley Slamat Attorneys – no games, JUST LAW™
Search & seizure laws in terms of the South African Police Service Act 68 of 1995 (PSA)
In terms of section 13(6) of the PSA a police official may search without a warrant any person, premises, other place, vehicle, vessel or aircraft or any receptacle, and seize any article that is found and may lawfully be seized.
The apparent aim of such a search is to exercise control over the illegal movement of people or goods across the borders of South Africa. The search may be conducted:
- at any place in South Africa within 10 kilometers, or any reasonable distance from any border between South Africa and any foreign state;
- in the territorial waters of South Africa;
- inside South Africa within 10 kilometers of or any reasonable distance from such territorial waters; or
- at any airport or within any reasonable distance from such an airport.
Section 13(7) of the PSA provides for searches in an area cordoned off for purposes of public order or safety.
The National or a Provincial Commissioner may, “where it is reasonable in the circumstances to restore public order or to ensure the safety of the public in a particular area”, authorize in writing that a particular area be cordoned off, specifying the period (which may not exceed 24 hours), the area and the object of the cordoning off.
On the strength of this authorization, a police official may, “where it is reasonably necessary” to achieve the objective of the authorization, conduct a search without a warrant (and presumably without reasonable grounds) of any person, premises, vehicle or receptacle or “any object of whatever nature” and seize any article that may afford evidence of the commission of an offence.
On the basis of such a broad purpose of the search, there may be substantial insufficient safeguards to achieve the necessary balance between the rights of citizens and law enforcement objectives.
The requirement of reasonable grounds for the search of individual premises may be abandoned, but the cordoning off of a particular area should be based on reasonable grounds.
Where it is reasonable in the circumstances in order to exercise a power or perform a function referred to in the Constitution, section 13(8)(a) of the PSA provides that the National or Provincial Commissioner may authorize a police official in writing to set up:
- a roadblock(s) on any public road in a particular area; or
- a checkpoint(s) at any public place in a particular area.
Section 13(8)(c) empowers a police official who is so authorized, to set up such a roadblock or checkpoint, as the case may be.
In terms of section 13(8)(g)(i) a police official who sets up such a roadblock or checkpoint may:
- search without a warrant any person or vehicle that is stopped or any receptacle or object of whatever nature that is in the possession or in, on or attached to such a vehicle, and
- seize any article referred to in section 20 of the CPA, that is found in the possession of the person or in, on or attached to the receptacle or vehicle.
The police official must, on demand of any person whose rights are or have been affected by the search and seizure, exhibit a copy of the written authorization to hold the roadblock or checkpoint.
In Sithonga v Minister of Safety and Security 2008 (1) SACR 376 the court maintained that section 13(8) restricted the setting up of checkpoints in public places. However, the Act did not define what a public place was. It was further held that an authorization in terms of the Act must describe the place where the checkpoint was to be set up with sufficient particularity and thus not be vague and ambiguously framed.
Section 13(8)(d) of the PSA, provides that a police official may set up a roadblock for the purposes of seizing ‘certain articles’ without written authorization from the National or a Provincial Commissioner, if such a police official reasonably believes that:
- there is an object which is concerned in, or may afford evidence of, or is intended to be used in the commission of an offence listed in Schedule 1 of the CPA, and
- such an object is present in or is about to be transported in a motor vehicle in a particular area, and
- a search warrant will be issued to him or her under section 21(1)(a) of the CPA if he or she has reason to believe that the object will be transported in a specific vehicle and he or she has applied for a search warrant, and
- the delay that will be caused by obtaining the authorisation in terms of section 13(8)(a) (from the National or Provincial Commissioner) will defeat the purpose of the roadblock.
In such circumstances a roadblock can be set up by such a police official on any public road or roads in that area in order to determine if a vehicle is in fact carrying such an object.
The requirement that a Commissioner may exercise this power only where it is “reasonable in the circumstances” imposes an objective test to be applied in law. The purpose of the roadblock should be reasonable.
A specified objective for the roadblock should be determined, the objective of which can be assessed.
A general crime prevention roadblock grants police officers unstructured search powers which are open to abuse and arbitrary, corrupt action, while a limited objective, such as the search for weapons or drugs, should result in focused and confined police actions which respect the rule of law and constitutional rights of citizens.
The legalization of cannabis use and possession in South Africa will undoubtedly bring all the above search and seizure laws into play.
www.slamatlaw.co.za Ashley Slamat Attorneys – Copyright
by slamatattorneys | Jun 21, 2021 | Criminal Law
What Constitutes a Legal Search & Seizure? (Part 1)
Search and seizure in terms of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 (CPA). In South African law the terms ‘search’ and ‘seizure’ are not clearly defined.
Undoubtedly, the legalization of cannabis use and possession in South Africa will test the current search and seizure laws to the fullest extent.
The consideration of what is a ‘search’ is dealt with while understanding that there is an inevitable physical intrusion in regard to a person or property which is necessary to establish a search. This causes a clash between criminal law principles and the Constitutionally guaranteed rights of every citizen.
It is important to understand that where a word is not defined in a particular piece of legislation that word then bears its ordinary meaning in law and hence in court proceedings.
Various sections of the CPA deal with search and seizures, we touch on a few in this article. It is critical to understand that significant legal principles and case law decisions qualify and/or delineate the black-letter of these sections of the CPA.
Search of arrested persons
Section 23 of the CPA provides for the search of arrested persons and the seizure of articles pursuant to the arrest, but clearly not for any other purpose, reason or event.
On the arrest of any person, the person effecting the arrest may:
- if s/he is a peace officer, search the person arrested and seize any article referred to in section 20, which is found in the possession of or in the custody or under the control of the person arrested, and where such a peace officer is not a police official, s/he shall forthwith deliver any such article to a police official; or
- if s/he is not a peace officer, seize any article referred to in section 20 which is in the possession of or in the custody or under the control of the person arrested and shall forthwith deliver any such article to a police official.
In South African law a peace officer may without a warrant effect a search of an arrested person and seize any article found in the possession, custody or control, of the arrested person, which may afford evidence of the commission of an offence of which such person is suspected.
Furthermore, the peace officer may place in safe custody (which implies that a documented chain of evidence record be kept) any object found on the person of the arrested person, which the arrested person may use to cause bodily injury to the arrested person or other persons.
Search of premises (does not necessarily include vehicles, animals, out houses, tents, barns or other separate structures on the land or premises)
Section 24 of the CPA provides for the search of premises.
Any person who is lawfully in charge or occupation of any land and who reasonably suspects that stolen stock or produce, as defined in any law relating to the theft of stock or produce, is on any premises upon that land, or that any article has been placed on such premises or is in the custody or possession of any person upon such premises in contravention of any law relating to intoxicating liquor, dependence-producing drugs, arms and ammunition or explosives, may at any time, if a police official is not readily available, enter such premises with the purpose of searching such premises and any such person thereon, and if any such stock, produce or article is found, he shall take possession thereof and forthwith deliver it to a police official.
State security – Power of the police to enter premises
Section 25 of the CPA empowers a police official to enter premises in connection with state security. This must be treated with caution and circumspection.
If it appears to a magistrate on oath that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the internal security of the Republic or the maintenance of law and order is likely to be endangered by or in consequence of any meeting which has been held or is to be held in or upon any premises within his area of jurisdiction, or that an offence has been or is likely to be committed or that preparations for the commission of any offence are being made or are likely to be made upon any premises within his area of jurisdiction, he may issue a warrant authorizing a police official to enter the premises at any reasonable time for the purposes of carrying out such investigations and taking such steps as such a police official may consider necessary for the preservation of law and order or the prevention of crime.
Entering of premises for purposes of obtaining evidence
Section 26 of the CPA provides for the entering of premises by a police official for the purposes of obtaining evidence.
If a police official who is investigating an offence or alleged offence reasonably suspects that a person who may furnish information with reference to such an offence is on any premises, such a police official may enter such premises without a warrant for the purposes of interrogating such a person and obtaining a statement from him, provided that such a police official shall not enter any private dwelling without the consent of the occupier thereof.
Search and other affected rights
Since a search may also infringe upon, inter alia, the rights to dignity and to bodily security the search must be conducted in harmony with and with respect for those rights at all times. In terms of section 29 of the CPA the search of a person must be conducted with strict regard to decency and order.
Seizure
In Ntoyakhe v Minister of Safety and Security 2000 (1) SA 257 the court held that the word ‘seize’ encompasses not only the act of taking possession of an article, but also the subsequent detention thereof (but not indefinite detention thereof), failing which the right to seize would be rendered worthless.
Seizure under or in terms of a search warrant
It is critical to know that in terms of section 21 of the CPA, unless the circumstances set out in section 22, 24 and 25 of the CPA exist, an article may be seized only in terms of a search warrant.
If it appears to a magistrate or justice of the peace that there are grounds for believing that such an article is in the possession or under the control of a person or upon any premises, and such information is provided to him or her under oath, a search warrant may be issued. In order for the search to be lawful, the premises to be searched must be clearly and properly identified in the warrant.
A search warrant must be executed during daylight hours unless the police official is specifically authorized therein to execute it at night.
Objective grounds for the search must exist.
The protection against an unjustified interferences with citizens’ right to privacy and other fundamental rights include prior judicial authorization and an objective standard, that is whether there are reasonable grounds (also known as reasonable suspicion or reasonable belief) to believe or suspect based on information obtained under oath that an offence has been or is likely to be committed, that the articles sought or seized may provide evidence of the commission of the offence and that the articles are likely to be on the premises to be searched.[1]
The essence of reasonable grounds is that such grounds or beliefs must be objective and reviewable by a court of law. Reasonable suspicion can be obtained through the utilization of the human senses of a police official in the course of duty.
A police official may without a search warrant search any person or container or premises for the purpose of seizing any article referred to in section 20:
- if the person concerned consents to the search for and seizure of the article in question;
- if the police official on reasonable grounds believes that a search warrant will be issued to him under section 21 of the CPA and that the delay in obtaining such a warrant would defeat the object of the search.
Undoubtedly, the legalization of cannabis use and possession in South Africa will test the above laws to the fullest extent.
www.slamatlaw.co.za
[1] In Rajah v Chairperson: North West Gambling Board 2006 3 All SA 172 (T) 394 the high court held that for a search and seizure to be valid in terms of s 21 of the Criminal Procedure Act, “a warrant may only be issued by a magistrate or judicial officer where it appears from information on oath that there are reasonable grounds for believing that an article is in possession or under the control of or at a premises within the area of jurisdiction of that particular officer”… further that the high court had a wide discretion to interfere with the magistrate’s decision if the court a quo had not applied its mind to the matter.”
by slamatattorneys | May 27, 2021 | Arbitration
ARBITRATION CLAUSE DISPUTES
ARBITRATION – WHEN IS A DISPUTE ARBITRABLE?
It seems that many parties do not know when a dispute is arbitrable. This article is provided as insight into this elementary issue which vexes so many. Bridging dispute resolution disputes is invaluable legal acumen.
A dispute is arbitrable when the dispute is one which the parties agree to be arbitrated. This ‘agreement’ is usually contained in a clause which is part of a contract which the parties have entered into at some prior time. In other words, the dispute is arbitrable by agreement between the parties as a form as alternative dispute resolution, i.e. alternative to formal court proceedings.
A dispute can also be arbitrable in terms of statutory provisions such as in terms of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995, as amended, which provides for certain disputes to be arbitrated by law (as opposed to by agreement) under the auspices of the CCMA or Bargaining Councils.
In either of the aforementioned instances, the actual dispute to be arbitrated is determined by the scope of the arbitration clause in the prior agreement or by the relevant statutory provisions. Thus in the former instance, the parties’ contract could provide for arbitration if the dispute is one which is in regard to matters such as:
-
- quantification of damages,
- appointment of accountants to consider and/or determine certain financial calculations,
- or financial valuations of assets or businesses or future financial disbursements where the parties are in disagreement,
- or there is a deadlock in a company’s board of directors in regard to the company’s business or asset valuations.
In addition to the above, it sometimes occurs that certain kinds of ‘technical legal’ issues arise in regard to the arbitration actually taking place in the first place, despite the parties having an agreement which provided for arbitration.
-
- Essentially, these ‘technical legal’ disputes can be in respect of issues such as:
- the arbitrator’s power or jurisdiction over the parties and/or the dispute itself,
- or whether a particular dispute which has arisen is one which the parties contemplated to be arbitrable in terms of their prior contract. eg. If one party contends that the prior agreement is void or invalid in law, is the right to refer the dispute to arbitration compromised or unenforceable? Or can the arbitrator arbitrate this contention as part of the arbitration of the actual dispute, or is it only a court of law which can adjudicate upon that contention before the arbitration itself proceeds in regard to the dispute?
Stated differently, the ‘technical legal’ issue is whether or not the ‘dispute’ falls within the enabling clause of a contract which provides for referral of the ‘dispute’ to arbitration. In many instances, one or both of the parties challenge the referral to arbitration of the basis that the ‘dispute’ is not one which the parties agreed could be referred to arbitration in terms of the arbitration clause of the contract.
In addition, it may also occur that one of the parties challenges the jurisdiction of the arbitrator to determine certain aspects of the arbitration clause and/or the arbitration itself. An example is when one of the parties challenges the coming into existence of the contract itself on the basis that it is void ab initio or alternatively invalid in which case the party contends that by necessary implication the arbitration clause is unenforceable itself, unless the principle of severability A further implication of such a challenge is that such party will then contend or argue that the arbitrator cannot determine these fundamental issues himself or herself and that only a court of law can do so.
In many of these instances involving arbitration clause disputes, the other party will contend that the arbitration clause is not automatically unenforceable or that the arbitrator is not incapable of determining these issues because they want to proceed with the arbitration of the dispute as opposed to becoming embroiled in courtroom litigation.
Fortunately, the courts in South Africa have provided some authority for the determination of these problematic issues in regard to arbitration clause disputes.
In the matter of North East Finance (Pty) Ltd v Standard Bank[1], the Supreme Court of Appeal held that it is in principle possible for the parties to agree that the question of the validity or voidness of their agreement be determined by the arbitrator himself/herself as part of the referral to the arbitration, provided the contract contains a term to that effect.
Thus, in layman’s terms where the contract or agreement limits the powers of the arbitrator either expressly or by implication (or does not provide for such power at all), the arbitrator cannot exceed his or her powers to arbitrate issues which he or she is not empowered to arbitrate. This ultimately means that the drafting of the agreement is of the utmost importance to ensure that the parties’ intention is at all material times recorded precisely in the agreement.
In the recent cases of City of Cape Town v Namasthethu[2] and Seabeach Property Investment 28 v Nunn[3], the Western Cape High Court dealt with two arbitration ‘technical legal’ disputes.
In the former case, the parties were in dispute regarding the actual validity of their contract in the first place.
- The question before the High Court was whether or not the legal ‘validity’ of their contract was an issue/dispute which they had contemplated to be one which was included in the clause enabling the arbitration of disputes arising from the contract.
- In casu, it was alleged that the contract itself was induced by fraudulent misrepresentation.
- The City of Cape Town contended that the validity of the contract was never an issue which was to be adjudicated upon, i.e. to be arbitrated, and that only a court of law could determine the validity of the contract.
- Upon consideration of the contract and the arbitration clause in question, the Court found that it did not appear that the parties contemplated that the validity of the contract itself was an issue which would be arbitrable, thus the issue of the validity of the contract could not be adjudicated upon by the arbitrator.
- The Court’s view was that if the validity of the contract itself was an issue/dispute which the parties intended to be resolved by adjudication or arbitration then the contract or the arbitration clause in the contract should specifically say so or the contract must clearly indicate as much from its terms.
- The Court went further to state that it so was because the general position is clear that if there is a dispute as to whether the contract which contains the arbitration clause is legally valid (or in other words, has ever been entered into at all) then this is issue cannot go to adjudication or arbitration under that arbitration clause itself. This position would only change if the parties made a provision for such referral in the arbitration clause, and same would require very clear language in the arbitration clause itself.
In the Seabeach case, the parties were in dispute in regard to the whether or not the contract concluded between them was void ab initio. i.e from the outset.
-
- The Respondent contended that if the contract itself was void ab initio, then all clauses of the contract would likewise be void ab initio including the arbitration clause of the contract.
- Upon consideration of the contract and the arbitration clause, the Court found that the termination or invalidity of the contract did not affect the arbitration clause of the contract because the parties had intended at the time of concluding the agreement that all of their disputes (including whether or not the agreement was valid or not) would be referred to arbitration because of the wording of the arbitration clause itself.
- The Court went on to state that to view the arbitration clause differently would give the contract a commercially insensible meaning which could not have been intended on the facts.
- Furthermore, that the parties had intended to ring-fence their agreement to proceed to arbitration, with the effect that even if the underlying or main contract was invalid or void, this would not affect the validity or enforceability of the arbitration clause of the underlying contract.
If regard is had to the North East Finance (Pty) Ltd case supra and the two recent Western Cape decisions, we recommend that any contract which is to include a referral to arbitration clause, should at all times be considered, drafted and executed by an attorney who is familiar with such terms and the applicable law.
Article published courtesy of RexLex™ Mediations & Arbitrations
www.rexlex.co.za
010 300 0825
Copyright 2021 RexLex™
[1] 2013 (5) SA 1(SCA)
[2] 2019 1 All SA 634 (WCC)
[3] 2019 ZAWCHC 9